Archive for February, 2008

guest post

by Robert Mellin, MRAIC, Associate Professor, School of Architecture, McGill University

I have focused on Griffintown this past year in my Cultural Landscapes post-professional program studio at McGill’s School of Architecture. My students have been documenting the history of particular places in Griffintown. For example, thus far we have documented the Griffintown Horse Palace (dates from the 1840’s!) in minute detail, with drawings, photographs, and interviews. For further information on this, see our archive of fieldwork at http://www.arch.mcgill.ca/prof/mellin/ssac/griffintown.html.

Three teams of students worked on different subjects: mapping, the stables, and what we called “the intangible” — photos, interviews, and sense of place. At present, another graduate student is doing a more comprehensive overview of the area’s architectural history and development over time.

Development of the Griffintown area should be permitted to happen in a long-term, incremental way so as to repair the damage wrought by drastic urban renewal and the forced resettlement of residents in the area. However, guidelines could be put in place for model sustainable development, with the possibility that a truly innovative and thoughtful New Urbanist project could evolve over time. There are many more than twelve historic buildings in Griffintown today, and my understanding is that in the present development proposal, only twelve will be saved. Griffintown still has a surprising number of historic buildings, and it is not just the buildings that should be considered. The old pattern of the streets, the traces of the past and fragments of industry along the Lachine Canal, and many other features could be incorporated into thoughtful development.

The main opportunity in Griffintown is to revive the area through a vision of a “living/working” quasi-industrial, but urban landscape of production, rather than a strictly “pleasure-oriented” landscape of consumption, with its attendant banal condos, parks, and shopping malls. Griffintown may once again become an important area not only for higher-density living, but also for light industry in a mixed-use zoning plan; as Norbert Schoenauer, Emeritus Professor at McGill demonstrated in his books and lectures, high density does not necessarily translate into “high-rise.” If James Howard Kunstler is correct with his predictions in his book The Long Emergency (excerpt here), in the near future the Lachine Canal may once again come into its own as an important transportation link in relation to light industry.

Robert Mellin, MRAIC, is an Associate Professor at the School of Architecture at McGill University and a registered architect. In recognition of his architectural design and restoration work, he was elected to membership in the Royal Canadian Academy of Arts in 2002. He is Chair of the board of directors of the Heritage Foundation of Newfoundland and Labrador. His book on the architecture of Tilting, Fogo Island, (Tilting: House Launching, Slide Hauling, Potato Trenching, and Other Tales from a Newfoundland Fishing Village), published by Princeton Architectural Press in New York, won the Winterset Literary Award in 2003. Robert Mellin has received a Manning Award and seven Southcott Awards (Newfoundland Historic Trust) for his heritage conservation work in Newfoundland. He received the 2006 Paul E. Buchanan Award for excellence in fieldwork and interpretation from the Vernacular Architecture Forum.

Read Full Post »

Tonight, Thursday Feb 21st, marks the launch of the all-too-brief official public consultation process on Projet Griffintown. In a mere 6 to 8 hours of public discussion, the fate of a 200-year-old sector of the city will be decided. And Montrealers will have to live with that decision for the next hundred years. We had better get it right.

Questions have been raised by residents, neighbors, scholars and experts.

  • First on our list are the absolutely undemocratic methods used to push this project through City Hall, circumventing normal oversight processes.
  • Second, the character of the development seems to be completely foreign to Montreal’s DNA; condos and shopping malls do not a neighborhood make.
  • Third, will this project saddle the city with another Olympic-sized debt, as it pays for infrastructure costs, and gives away cheap land to its corporate pals?
  • And fourth, knowing the nature of the world to come — where cheap energy is no longer predictable, leading to problems in our happy globalized economy well before it “runs out” — is this project really sustainable?

We invite you to read the attached documents, which include the report from the city’s own Heritage Commission, op-eds from Heritage Montreal, architects / professors Raphael Fischler and Jean-Claude Marsan, urbanist Steven Peck, and residents Chris and Judith Gobeil.

Then, we ask that you join us tonight at the ETS (corner of Peel and Notre-Dame) to listen to the City’s and Devimco’s presentations, and then to ask some tough questions. We’ll be there: will you?

Avis Officiel du Conseil du Patrimoine (pdf, en français)

Des Principes à Respecter (Heritage Montreal op-ed from Le Devoir, PDF)

Projet Griffintown: Catalyse ou cataclysme? Raphael Fischler Op-Ed, Le Devoir (.doc)

Montréal mérite mieux (Montreal Deserves Better), Jean-Claude Marsan (.doc)

Projet Griffintown: Ce que la collectivité à a perdre (What the community stands to lose) (PDF)

Griffintown n’a pas besoin d’un mégaprojet

Read Full Post »

Bienvenue au site Web du Comité pour le sain rédeveloppement de Griffintown, une groupe de résidents, de conseillers spécialisés et de citoyens concernés ou intéressés. Vous trouverez ici des nouvelles, des liens, des informations de base, des communiqués de presse et nos exposés de principe, ainsi que des images et des documents sur le rédeveloppement du quartier Griffintown. Nous nous intéressons particulièrement au Plan particulier d’urbanisme (PPU) pour le secteur Peel-Wellington, créé par l’administration municipale pour encadrer le mégaprojet du promoteur Devimco.

Welcome to the public website for the Committee for the Sustainable Redevelopment of Griffintown, a group composed of area residents, advisors and citizens. We’ll be posting news, links, background articles, press releases, position papers, images and documents here in order to keep the media and the general public better informed about redevelopment efforts in Griffintown, most notably the city’s Special Planning Program (SPP) for the Peel-Wellington area and the related Devimco megaproject.

Read Full Post »